ON USER ONBOARDING — STEP 3: SUCCESS MILESTONES
Navigating User Onboarding: The Importance of Having a Clear Direction
A step-by-step approach to determining your PAI for superior onboarding and qualified lead generation
The 7 steps approach to user onboarding
Step 0: From First Moments to Lasting Engagement
Step 2: Understanding the users
Step 3: Defining success and its milestones
Why having a clear direction is vital for navigating the user onboarding journey
In the user onboarding journey, direction is key, and understanding user needs is paramount. By defining success through critical milestones, you create a roadmap for users to follow. Clear direction, coupled with an understanding of user needs and progress-making forces, can transform the onboarding experience, ensuring users reach their desired destination — becoming loyal, engaged customers.
The relevance of direction in User Onboarding
Imagine embarking on a road trip without GPS or a roadmap. You may start confidently, but sooner or later, you’ll realize you’re lost. Similarly, in user onboarding, it’s crucial to provide users with a clear path to their desired destination. Just as GPS guides us, a well-structured onboarding process should guide users through the product.
The parallel here is that, just as GPS takes us from point A to point B, user onboarding takes users from being new and uncertain to being engaged and proficient users of a product. Without this direction, users can feel lost, and frustrated, and may even abandon the journey altogether.
Emphasizing the significance of having a clear path
Clear direction in user onboarding means giving users a roadmap to success. It involves providing them with the right information, guidance, and tools at each step of their journey. When users know what to expect and how to navigate your product, they’re more likely to stay engaged and ultimately become loyal customers.
Having a clear path also means reducing friction in the onboarding process. It minimizes the chances of users getting stuck or confused along the way. Just as a well-marked highway is easier to follow, a well-designed onboarding process leads users smoothly toward their destination.
Highlighting the consequences of not knowing the desired destination
In user onboarding, not knowing the desired destination can have adverse effects. Users may feel lost, and uncertain, and eventually give up on your product.
When users don’t understand the value or purpose of your product, they’re less likely to see the benefits it offers. They may abandon it in search of a more straightforward solution. In other words;
Not having a clear destination in mind can lead to churn and missed opportunities
Understanding user needs and progress-making forces
Before you can provide users with a clear direction, you must understand their needs and desires. This involves identifying their desired outcomes, commonly referred to as Jobs-to-Be-Done (JTBD). JTBD theory helps uncover why users “hire” your product and what they aim to achieve.
By knowing these user needs, you can tailor your onboarding process to address them directly. For example, if users seek a design tool to create stunning graphics quickly, your onboarding should highlight this capability.
Furthermore, user decisions aren’t arbitrary; they’re influenced by progress-making forces. These forces determine whether users will continue their journey with your product or abandon it.
The four primary progress-making forces include:
- “The Push” to Find a New Solution Due to Current Problems: Users seek new solutions when their current situation becomes problematic.
- “The Pull” of What Could Be Achieved with This New Product: Users are drawn to new products when they see potential benefits.
- “The Anxiety” Around the Risks of Moving to a New Product: Users may be hesitant to switch due to concerns about risks and uncertainties.
- “The Inertia” of Not Wanting to Change: People resist change, even if a new solution promises benefits. Inertia can keep users stuck in their current situation.
Understanding these forces allows you to address them proactively in your onboarding process.
Defining onboarding success milestones and key criteria
Now that we’ve stressed the importance of direction and understanding user needs, let’s move on to defining success in the user onboarding journey. Knowing what success looks like is as crucial as knowing the destination itself.
Identification of critical success moments
Success in user onboarding isn’t a single event; it’s a series of milestones. Three pivotal moments matter most when measuring onboarding success:
- Moment of Value Perception: This is when users complete the signup process; the beginning of the journey, where users show initial interest in your product.
- Moment of Value Experience: This is when users experience the value of the product for the first time. This is when users grasp the benefits your product offers.
- Moment of Value Adoption: This is when users begin to use your product Consistently: The point where users adopt your product as part of their routine.
Success Criteria #1: The signup process — unlocking the gateway to User Engagement
When it comes to user onboarding, the signup process serves as the threshold between potential users and the immersive realm of your product. It’s much more than a routine digital form-filling exercise; it’s the portal through which users express their intent to explore your offering.
- Completion of the signup — The starting point of the journey: The user’s journey commences with the completion of the signup process. At this stage, they mark their interest in what your product has to offer. However, this journey can vary dramatically based on how you’ve designed this initial interaction. The ease or complexity of the signup process plays a vital role in shaping the nature of the users you attract.
Imagine the signup process as a path: a smooth, well-paved road encourages more travelers, while a bumpy, obstacle-laden trail might deter all but the most committed explorers.
For instance, if your product demands credit card details upfront for a free trial, you might observe a lower quantity of signups.
However, these signups often represent a more dedicated cohort of users who are more likely to convert into paying customers. Thus, understanding the dynamics of this process is crucial to strike the right balance between attracting a broad user base and ensuring their commitment.
- Opt-In vs. Opt-Out trials — Navigating the decision: One of the most critical choices in structuring your signup process revolves around opt-in and opt-out trials. This decision wields profound influence over user behavior and the nature of your user base. Choosing between opt-in and opt-out trials is a complex decision that involves weighing various factors. It’s not a one-size-fits-all choice. Your selection should align with your product’s goals and your target audience’s preferences. If you aim to attract a large user base for extensive trial testing, opt-in trials may be more suitable. Conversely, if your priority is to secure committed users who are likelier to convert, opt-out trials may be the better choice.
Opt-In Trials: In an opt-in trial, users willingly and actively opt to participate in your trial or free access. This typically involves a straightforward signup process without immediate financial commitments. While it might lead to higher initial signup numbers due to the lower barrier to entry, it often results in lower conversion rates. Users are exploring your product without a strong initial commitment, which means they might not be as invested in the long run.
Opt-Out Trials: On the flip side, opt-out trials automatically enroll users in the trial or free access. Users are required to opt-out if they don’t wish to proceed. These trials often necessitate providing payment details upfront, although users usually have the option to cancel before any charges apply. Opt-out trials tend to yield higher conversion rates, as users have already taken the initial step of commitment by signing up. They are more likely to continue using and, ultimately, paying for your product.
The signup process is not merely a point of entry; it’s a strategic gateway to user engagement. Understanding its nuances, from the completion of the signup process to the choice between opt-in and opt-out trials, is paramount in steering your user onboarding journey effectively. Balancing the quantity and quality of signups while aligning with your product’s goals will play a pivotal role in the success of your onboarding efforts.
Success Criteria #2: The ‘first strike ‘— Accelerating users toward desired outcomes
At its essence, the ‘First Strike’ embodies the crucial action that users must take to accomplish their desired outcome or Customer Job. While this concept remains consistent across various products, the specific nature of the First Strike can vary significantly. To illustrate this diversity, consider the following examples:
- In a design software application like Canva, the First Strike might involve exporting or sharing a completed design.
- For a video conferencing tool like Zoom, the First Strike could entail either hosting or attending a meeting.
- On a team communication and collaboration software such as Slack, the first 2000 messages can be the First Strike.
The significance of identifying the First Strike lies in its ability to propel users directly toward their intended goal with your product. It’s that pivotal step that bridges the gap between intention and accomplishment, ensuring that users swiftly engage with your product’s core functionalities.
- Challenges in identifying the First Strike — Identifying the First Strike isn’t always a straightforward process, especially for products that offer a myriad of functionalities. Imagine attempting to pinpoint the First Strike for an all-in-one product, much like a digital Swiss Army knife. The complexity arises because various user segments may have distinct initial needs and objectives when using the product.
- Context and user segmentation: In this scenario, context and user segmentation emerge as indispensable tools for unraveling the appropriate First Strike. By considering the context of use and understanding the specific requirements of different user segments, you can identify various First Strikes that cater to the diverse needs of your user base. For instance, a versatile tool like Intercom, which offers solutions for customer support, engagement, and marketing, might yield different First Strikes based on the user’s particular use case. This contextual approach allows you to tailor the onboarding experience to the unique expectations and objectives of various user segments, ensuring that each group experiences a First Strike that resonates with their specific needs.
- Alignment with Customer Jobs — The North Star of Onboarding Success: Crucially, the First Strike should closely align with the core Customer Job(s) that your product is designed to address. This alignment serves as the compass guiding users toward their intended outcomes. When the First Strike harmonizes with the fundamental objectives of your product, it becomes the first tangible sign of onboarding success. It indicates that new users are not merely engaging with your product but are actively taking meaningful steps toward accomplishing their desired outcomes.
The Second Success Criterion — the First Strike — is a pivotal moment in the user onboarding journey. It represents the critical action that bridges intention and achievement, guiding users toward their desired outcomes or Customer Jobs. Navigating the complexity of identifying the First Strike requires a contextual approach and careful consideration of user segmentation. When the First Strike aligns seamlessly with your product’s core objectives, it serves as the initial beacon of onboarding success, signaling that users are well on their way to achieving their goals with your product.
Success Criteria #3: Unlocking the Path to Habitual Product Use: The Tipping Point
User onboarding, a critical phase in the user journey, hinges on a series of well-defined success criteria. While the completion of the signup process and achieving the first product interaction represent pivotal milestones, there’s a third, equally vital measure of success that often eludes many: the Tipping Point.
- The pursuit of habit formation — A fundamental onboarding objective: User onboarding, at its core, aims to transform first-time users into loyal, habitual consumers of your product. This objective goes beyond mere initial interactions; it seeks to instill a routine where users consistently engage with your offering. The true magic of onboarding unfolds when users not only perceive your product’s value but integrate it into their daily lives. Consider Slack, a prime example of rigorous onboarding standards. For Slack, the onboarding journey isn’t deemed successful until a team has exchanged approximately 2,000 messages. This seemingly high bar signifies that the team has reached the Tipping Point and is likely to continue using Slack as their primary communication tool.
- The Tipping Point — A Defining Moment in Onboarding: The Tipping Point signifies a transformational juncture in a user’s journey. It marks the transition from a skeptical or sporadic user to a devoted, habitual consumer of your product. Users who reach this milestone are unlikely to revert to their previous habits or tools. Their embrace of your product is a profound indication of future user retention and product adoption, often termed the “Product Adoption Indicator” or PAI.
- The “Magic Number” Phenomenon: While the notion of a PAI may sound innovative, it’s worth noting that it’s not entirely new. Some refer to it as the “magic number.” Numerous renowned platforms have utilized this concept to bolster user retention:
Facebook’s magic number is tied to users adding seven friends within their first 10 days on the platform
Twitter’s early success was partly attributed to users following 30 accounts, encouraging engagement
Dropbox observed that users who uploaded a file to a single folder on one device were more likely to upload additional files
Each of these PAIs is intricately linked to user retention, serving as early indicators that users are forging a habit of using the product.
Once users cross this threshold, they’ve effectively perceived, experienced, and adopted your product, setting them on the path to sustained engagement.
5 key characteristics of effective PAIs
Effective PAIs share several essential characteristics that contribute to their success:
- Leading Indicators of User Retention: PAIs serve as precursors to user retention, much like the canary in a coal mine, forewarning of hazardous gases. They provide early signals that users are forming a lasting product habit, instilling confidence in their continued engagement.
- Focus on Repetition of Key Actions: Recognizing that habit formation hinges on repetition, PAIs emphasize consistent engagement in a specific, vital product action. These actions align with the desired outcomes or Customer Jobs the product fulfills.
- Simplicity and Communicability: PAIs are designed to be uncomplicated, easy to remember, and readily communicated throughout the organization. Simplicity, as seen in Facebook’s “add seven friends in 10 days” mantra, ensures clarity and widespread understanding.
- Time-Bound: Ideally, PAIs should be associated with a specific timeframe within which users should accomplish them. This temporal aspect aids in assessing user progress and allows for timely adjustments to the onboarding process if required.
- Early in the User Journey: PAIs should be attainable early in a user’s journey, providing swift insights into their trajectory toward success. Delayed PAIs, occurring weeks after sign-up, yield fewer data points due to user attrition.
Understanding and optimizing the Tipping Point and its associated PAI can significantly enhance the effectiveness of your user onboarding process. It’s the stage where users evolve from mere product dabblers into devoted enthusiasts, forming lasting habits that drive long-term engagement.
By recognizing the significance of this juncture and aligning your strategies accordingly, you can chart a course toward higher user satisfaction, greater retention rates, and a flourishing product ecosystem.
A five-step guide to determining your PAI
The Product Adoption Indicator (PAI) is a game-changer in user onboarding. It’s the compass that guides your efforts in ensuring users not only sign up but also engage and continue using your product. By following the following five steps you can unlock the full potential of your PAI, enhancing user success, and ultimately driving product adoption to new heights. Remember, while the term “PAI” may vary among companies, the underlying concept remains constant — it’s about ensuring your users find value and keep coming back.
Step 1: Get a baseline measurement of your retention
Retention is not just a buzzword; it’s the pulse of your product’s success. It signifies how effectively you’re able to capture and retain users’ interest over time. Think of it as the heartbeat of your product — steady and strong, and you want it to stay that way.
Retention is like the roots of a tree. The deeper and stronger they are, the healthier and more resilient the tree becomes. Similarly, high retention rates indicate that your users are not just trying out your product and leaving; they’re sticking around because they find value in it. This is vital for any product’s long-term sustainability. Without a solid foundation of user retention, your product may struggle to grow and thrive.
- The significance of a baseline measurement: Before you dive into finding your PAI, you need to understand where you currently stand. This is where establishing a baseline measurement of your retention rates comes into play. It’s like knowing your starting point on a map before you plan your journey.
- Steps for Baseline Measurement: 1) Choose your key metrics: Begin by deciding what retention metrics matter most to your product. Are you interested in daily, weekly, or monthly retention rates? Select the time frame that aligns with your product’s usage patterns. 2) Use analytics tools: There are powerful analytics tools like Mixpanel or Amplitude designed to make this process more manageable. These tools can generate insightful reports illustrating your product’s retention curve, which visually shows how many users return and engage with your product over time. 3) Manual calculation: If you prefer a more hands-on approach or if you’re dealing with limited resources, you can calculate retention manually using spreadsheet software like Excel or Google Sheets.
Manual calculation of retention
i) Start with a specific cohort of users, such as those who signed up on a particular date.
ii) Track the number of users from this cohort who remain active over a set period (e.g., from Day 1 to Day 7).
iii) Divide the number of users who stuck around by the total number of users in the cohort.
iv) Multiply the result by 100 to express it as a percentage.
For example, if you started with 12,481 users on January 1 and want to calculate the user retention rate for the first seven days, you’d track new users signing up on January 1 and users active from Day 1 to Day 7. If 3,506 users from this cohort are still engaged after a week, your Day 7 retention rate is (3,506 / 12,481) * 100, which equals 28.1%.
Establishing this baseline provides clarity. It helps you understand how well you’re currently retaining users and gives you a reference point to evaluate the effectiveness of any changes you make in your onboarding process. It’s a crucial step towards building a more successful user journey.
Step 2: Create a PAI hypothesis — Crafting the blueprint
Having established your baseline retention curve, it’s time to build the blueprint for your PAI hypothesis. Think of this as the guiding star of your PAI journey, illuminating the path toward understanding when and why users stick with your product.
- The essence of a PAI hypothesis: Your PAI hypothesis is your North Star, the guiding principle that outlines the conditions under which users are most likely to become dedicated, long-term users of your product. It’s not just a guess; it’s a well-thought-out statement that provides direction to your efforts in user onboarding.
- Starting Point — Define a key product action: Every product has a core interaction that defines its purpose. For example, for WhatsApp, it’s the act of sending a message — the essence of communication. This key product action is at the heart of your PAI hypothesis. It’s the “aha” moment, the point where users experience the core value your product offers.
- Setting specific targets: Your hypothesis needs specificity. It’s not merely “users should engage with our product.” Instead, it might be “new users should send at least three messages on the day of signing up.” These targets give clarity to your hypothesis, making it actionable and measurable.
- Timing matters: Consider the timing within which these actions should occur. For many products, the initial days after sign-up are critical. Users should ideally accomplish this key product action early in their journey. For more complex products, especially in the B2B space, it might take a week or more to achieve this action, considering the setup and learning curve.
- Identifying retention stability: Your PAI hypothesis should also identify the point when user retention begins to stabilize. In other words, at what point do users transition from being casual or exploratory to committed and habitual? Analyze your retention curve to spot the inflection point where users start to “get” your product and are more likely to stick with it.
For example, in the case of WhatsApp, one key PAI hypothesis could be:
- Key Product Action: Sending a message.
- Specific Target: New users should send at least 3 messages on the day of signing up.
- Timing: Users should achieve this within their first interaction with the app.
- Retention Stability: Analyzing the retention curve might reveal that users who send three messages on the day of sign-up tend to stick around for an extended period.
Why This Matters
Your PAI hypothesis is your compass in the vast sea of user data. It gives you a clear direction on what actions matter the most for retaining users. Crafting this hypothesis is like creating a treasure map; it leads you to the gold — in this case, users who will not only adopt your product but become advocates and loyal customers. It’s the pivotal moment where theory becomes practice in your journey to improve user onboarding.
Step 3: Gather Data to Validate Your Hypothesis
With the PAI hypothesis crafted, it’s time to put it to the test. The key to making informed decisions lies in gathering and analyzing data that validates your hypothesis. This step is where you transform your educated guess into a data-backed strategy.
- The intersection of key actions and continued use: Your PAI hypothesis postulates that there’s a specific threshold of key actions performed by users that predicts their continued use of your product. In this step, you’re on a quest to identify that sweet spot, the precise point where users who perform the key action and continue using your product intersect.
- Finding the overlap: Imagine this as a Venn diagram. On one side, you have users who continue using your product after a specified time (say, in the case of WhatsApp, 21 days). On the other side, you have users who have performed the key product action (like sending 3 messages on the first day in WhatsApp). Your goal is to maximize the surface area where these two segments overlap.
- Three essential data segments: To conduct this analysis effectively, you’ll need to collect data on three specific user segments: i) Users who continue using your product after the specified time frame. These are the individuals who stick around and become long-term users. ii) Users who have performed the key action. These are the users who engaged with your product in a meaningful way, like sending those three crucial messages on day one. iii) Users who performed the key action but didn’t continue using your product. This group is equally important because it helps you avoid setting the threshold too low.
- Iterative exploration: Now, it’s time for experimentation. You don’t just set one threshold and hope for the best. Instead, you iterate this process with different thresholds to find the one that maximizes the overlap between these segments. You’re essentially searching for that magical number, the minimum key actions that correspond to users who will stay committed.
Let’s put this into perspective using WhatsApp:
- Specified time frame: 21 days
- Key action: Sending 3 messages on the first day
- Data collection: You gather data on users who continue using WhatsApp beyond 21 days, those who sent at least three messages on day one and continued, and those who sent three messages but didn’t continue.
- Why this process matters: This data-driven approach is the bridge between theory and reality. It provides empirical evidence to support your PAI hypothesis. It tells you if your chosen key action is indeed a reliable predictor of user retention. By iterating through different thresholds, you ensure that your PAI isn’t set too low or too high, but at that sweet spot that maximizes user retention.
In essence, this step transforms your PAI from a hypothetical idea into a practical tool for optimizing user onboarding and enhancing user success. It’s the moment when you turn data into actionable insights, paving the way for more effective user engagement strategies.
Step 4: Compare the retention curves and validate the PAI
After the rigorous data collection and analysis in the previous steps, it’s time to answer the pivotal question: Does your PAI genuinely impact user retention? This step is all about validation, confirming that your PAI is not just a theoretical concept but a practical tool for improving user success.
- A crucial validation process: The validation process here ensures that all the effort put into crafting and fine-tuning your PAI hypothesis translates into tangible results for your product’s user retention. It’s a pivotal checkpoint where you determine whether the selected key actions and thresholds have a meaningful impact on how users engage with and commit to your product.
- Comparing retention curves: To validate your PAI, you’ll perform a comparative analysis between two retention curves: 1) Users who meet your PAI criteria: These are the users who have engaged with your product in the specific way outlined by your PAI hypothesis. They’ve crossed the threshold you set. 2) Baseline retention curve: This represents the retention rates for all users, regardless of whether they met the PAI criteria.
- Seeking the difference: The essence of this step is to examine whether there’s a noticeable difference between these two curves. If your PAI is effective, you should observe a clear disparity in user retention rates. The curve for users who meet the PAI should ideally outperform the baseline retention curve. In essence, your PAI should identify users who are more likely to stick around and continue using your product.
- Advanced validation methods: While a visual comparison of retention curves is a straightforward way to validate your PAI, there are more advanced statistical methods available. One such method is logistic regression, which can provide a deeper level of analysis. This technique can help you explore the statistical relationship between meeting the PAI criteria and user retention more comprehensively.
- Why Validation Matters: The validation step is crucial for several reasons: i) Data-backed decision-making: It ensures that your PAI isn’t based on guesswork but on concrete evidence. When you can confidently say that users meeting the PAI criteria have significantly higher retention rates, you have a powerful tool for decision-making. 2) Resource allocation: It helps allocate your resources effectively. Once your PAI is validated, you can prioritize efforts to drive users to meet these criteria, knowing it’s directly linked to improved retention. 3) Iterative improvement: If you find that your initial PAI isn’t as effective as expected, this step provides the foundation for iterative improvements. You can adjust your key actions or thresholds based on data-driven insights.
Step 4 or the validation phase is the litmus test for your PAI’s effectiveness. It’s where theory meets reality, and you see whether your carefully crafted PAI has a meaningful impact on user retention. Successful validation sets the stage for implementing focused strategies to enhance user success and product adoption.
Step 5: Communicate your PAI and share the Insights
While discovering your PAI is important, it’s equally important to ensure that everyone in your organization understands its significance and actively works towards achieving it. Effective communication and alignment of teams are the keys to harnessing the power of your PAI.
- The PAI as a strategic metric: Your PAI isn’t just another metric; it’s a strategic compass that guides your organization toward user success and product adoption. It encapsulates the precise actions and conditions that drive users to become long-term, engaged customers. Therefore, its effective implementation and alignment with various teams within your organization are paramount.
- Making the PAI accessible: To ensure that your PAI is widely embraced and understood, you should make it as accessible as possible through i) having simplicity: by simplifying the PAI concept, avoiding jargon and complex definitions, crafting a straightforward and easy-to-understand statement that encapsulates what the PAI represents, and ii) visualization, aids can significantly enhance understanding like infographics or charts that illustrate the PAI and its impact on user retention, powerful tools during internal presentations and discussions.
- Alignment with marketing and sales teams: Your marketing and sales teams play a pivotal role in driving user acquisition and initial engagement. It’s crucial to align their efforts with the PAI. To align: i) Share the PAI: Provide marketing and sales teams with a clear understanding of the PAI. Explain how achieving the PAI translates into higher user retention and, ultimately, increased revenue. ii) Adjust Focus: Encourage marketing and sales teams to shift their focus from just acquiring new users to ensuring that these users reach the Moment of Value Adoption (defined by your PAI). Emphasize that quality is more important than quantity when it comes to users. iii) Track Progress: Implement systems to track progress towards the PAI. Regularly update marketing and sales teams on how their efforts are contributing to PAI achievement. Provide them with feedback and data on which strategies are most effective in guiding users to meet the PAI criteria.
- Enhancing Customer Support: Customer support teams are on the front lines when it comes to user interactions. They can play a pivotal role in ensuring that users receive the necessary guidance and support to reach the PAI. Here’s how to involve them: 1) Awareness and Training: Ensure that customer support teams are well-informed about the PAI and its significance. Train them to recognize users who are approaching the PAI threshold and provide them with additional support and guidance. 2) Feedback Loop: Establish a feedback loop between customer support and product development teams. Customer support can provide valuable insights into user pain points and barriers to meeting the PAI criteria, which can inform product improvements.
- Cultural Integration: For the PAI to become a driving force within your organization, it needs to be integrated into your organizational culture. Here’s how to achieve that: i) Frequent Communication: Keep the PAI on the radar by discussing it regularly in meetings, presentations, and internal communications. The more it’s talked about, the more ingrained it becomes in the company culture. ii) Recognition and Rewards: Consider recognizing and rewarding teams or individuals who contribute significantly to achieving the PAI. This not only incentivizes alignment with PAI goals but also highlights its importance.
Step 5 is all about ensuring that your PAI isn’t just a concept on paper but a dynamic, integrated part of your organization’s strategy. Effective communication, alignment with teams, and cultural integration are the pillars that transform your PAI into a powerful driver of user success and product adoption.
Hope you found this article useful!
If so, then:
- Follow me on Medium
- Become a Medium Member
- Subscribe to hear more
- Let’s connect on LinkedIn
Unlocking the power of Product Qualified Leads (PQLs) and the PAI
In the ever-evolving landscape of marketing and user acquisition, two essential metrics stand out: Product Qualified Leads (PQLs) and the Product Adoption Indicator (PAI). These metrics play a pivotal role in assessing a product’s performance and its users’ journey. However, understanding their relationship and how to harness their potential can be a game-changer for any organization.
PQL [Product Qualified Leads] vs. MQL [Marketing Qualified Leads]
Let’s begin by distinguishing between PQLs and the more commonly known Marketing Qualified Leads (MQLs). MQLs are identified based on somewhat arbitrary factors like email opens, whitepaper downloads, and webpage visits. These criteria, while helpful in their own right, don’t necessarily guarantee that the lead has found real value in your product. They indicate interest but not necessarily product adoption.
PQLs, on the other hand, represent a different breed of leads. These are users who have not just shown interest but have actively engaged with your product and derived meaningful value from it. They’ve reached a stage where the product has made a tangible impact on their needs or goals. As such, PQLs offer a unique opportunity for sales and support teams to focus their efforts on users who are more likely to become high-value customers.
The essence of PAI
The PAI is a metric that encapsulates the core essence of a user’s interaction with your product. It revolves around one key product action that signifies a user’s adoption of the product. It’s the “aha” moment when users realize the value your product brings to their lives.
The brilliance of PAI lies in its simplicity. It provides an easily communicable goal within your organization. This singular focus allows teams to rally around a common objective and align their efforts to drive users toward that pivotal action.
PQL’s versatility
While PAI centers on one crucial action, PQLs can be a bit more versatile.
PQLs are not limited to a single metric but can encompass a range of product engagement factors
This versatility allows organizations to fine-tune their lead qualification process to match the unique characteristics of their product.
Some considerations for PQLs might include:
- The frequency of a user’s return to the product
- Their exploration of various features, and
- The timeframe within which users engage with these features post-signup
This adaptability makes PQLs a more nuanced tool for identifying valuable users.
Potential Overlap
It’s worth noting that PQLs and PAI can intersect, but they don’t have to be identical. The degree of alignment between these two metrics depends on the organization’s resources and its capacity to provide personalized support to leads. If you have the resources to cater to a larger pool of potential users, you can lower the requirements for a PQL and align it with the moment users achieve their desired outcome. This approach can be particularly advantageous in scaling efforts to nurture leads effectively.
Real-world example — Slack
To illustrate this concept, let’s consider Slack.
- If Slack has only a handful of sales and support personnel, they might set the PQL threshold equivalent to Slack’s PAI, which could be something like 2,000 messages sent within the platform.
- However, if Slack decides to significantly expand its sales and support teams, it could adjust the PQL threshold downward to a more attainable level, such as when a team sends just ten messages. This adjustment opens the door to pursuing a larger number of PQLs, thereby expanding the potential customer base.
The role of product analytics tools
To effectively leverage both PQLs and PAI, you need robust product analytics tools in your arsenal. While tools like Google Analytics (GA) serve their purpose in measuring various aspects of user behavior, they often fall short when it comes to capturing the intricate details of user interactions within your product.
GA was originally designed for marketing analysis and may not inherently accommodate the depth and sophistication needed to understand the modern customer journey. Without predefined events, GA struggles to accurately measure product engagement. Moreover, GA aggregates data, making it challenging to discern the specific value individual users derive from your product.
The need for specialized tools
This is where specialized product analytics tools come into play. Platforms like Mixpanel, Heap Analytics, Amplitude, or PendO are purpose-built for tracking and analyzing product engagement metrics. These tools enable you to dive deep into user behavior, understand their preferences, and track meaningful events that indicate user satisfaction and engagement.
Custom metrics for unique products
One size doesn’t fit all when it comes to product analytics. Each product is unique, and the metrics that matter most will vary. For instance, for a B2B productivity tool, key product engagement metrics might include projects created, tasks completed, team members added, comments left, files uploaded, and projects completed. Meanwhile, a social networking application might prioritize metrics like connections made, published content, posts liked, and comments made. The key takeaway is that your product’s success metrics should be tailored to your product’s unique value proposition.
User-Level Tracking
Finally, it’s not just about measuring metrics at a high level; it’s about drilling down to the individual user level. Implementing a product analytics tool that tracks these metrics for each user provides a granular understanding of user behavior. This level of detail allows you to make informed decisions, personalize user experiences, and drive engagement effectively.
The dynamic interplay between PQLs and PAI holds immense potential for organizations looking to maximize their user acquisition and retention strategies. By understanding the nuances of these metrics and leveraging specialized product analytics tools, you can unlock valuable insights into user behavior, drive product adoption, and chart a course towards sustainable growth
